How would a pragmatist likely approach the analysis of the death penalty?

A pragmatist would approach the analysis of the death penalty by examining data to draw conclusions because pragmatism emphasizes practical outcomes and real-world implications of actions and policies. This approach involves looking at empirical evidence, such as statistical data on crime rates, execution rates, and the effects of the death penalty on society, to assess its efficacy and consequences. The pragmatist is likely to focus on how the death penalty operates within the criminal justice system and its impact on crime deterrence, justice, and societal attitudes.

This method prioritizes what works and is effective in practice over theoretical or abstract philosophical considerations, aligning with the core belief of pragmatism that the value of ideas and policies should be judged based on their actionable results and tangible benefits in real-world applications.